![]() |
| This is supposedly the location where Forrest Fenn's treasure was found. I drove right by it! |
Chasing the Thrill: Obsession, Death, and Glory in America's Most Extraordinary Treasure Hunt by Daniel BarbarisiMy rating: 5 of 5 stars
Slightly off-topic, but Ready Player One was AU Forrest Fenn fanfic, right? It’s got the same vibe of treasure seekers turned fanatics to a religious level, keyed into a cult of personality around the creator of the hunt, to such an extent that the treasure hunt is genuinely conflated with and requires an intimate knowledge of that creator. The only difference is that Ready Player One is the Mary Sue fanfic version in which the hunter succeeds because he works the hardest and has come to know the most about the creator, the hunt is solved in a way that provides everyone involved with full closure, and life becomes better in every way thanks to the treasure.
The real Forrest Fenn treasure hunt did not go that way. The winner wasn’t one of the more highly-engaged fanatics. He did not willingly offer closure to the masses of other eager treasure hunters. He only unwillingly offered what few details we currently have about the solution to the hunt and the location of the treasure after being wrongfully sued by a crazed fan. It’s unclear if anyone’s lives were made better, particularly the finder's thanks to the existence of apparently boundless crazed hunters, and it’s very clear that many lives were made much, much worse.
![]() |
| Here's the location of the treasure at the top compared to a couple of the search spots the author visited in the book. All the spots are within the boundary of Yellowstone National Park. |
Since the treasure hunt is concluded, I had a lot of fun reading through people’s “solves” in Barbarisi's book and then Google Mapping them to see how close they were. Most of them were not close, but it would probably kill you to have spent all that time searching Madison River but just… one mile too far downstream. I’d almost have rather been one of those New Mexico losers who were sooooo far off! I would have been very interested to see what these search moments looked like in the book’s draft that was written before the treasure hunt’s conclusion. I wonder if there were moments that would have attempted to foreshadow a different ending? I also would have been interested in maps of these various solve locations and images of what various hunters took to be their major clues. Like, one hunter claimed that a copse of trees looked like the Periodic Table of Elements and that was a clue? Picture, please!!! I’d love to someday explore the thesis that many of these hunters’ interpretations and solutions say much more about them than about the actual Fenn hunt.
![]() |
| We took a family trip to Yellowstone in 2014 and stayed in West Yellowstone, which means that we drove past the treasure twice a day and I probably could have met some hunters in the hotel restaurant if I'd known to look for them. In this photo, however, my partner and the big kid are not looking for treasure--they're looking at geysers! |
Barbarisi’s own participation-ish in the hunt gave out “Almost Famous” vibes, and I thought it was interesting to witness him, a full-on journalist, out there as hunt-crazy as the rest of the people he was profiling, trespassing on fragile natural features and wrecking the wonders of Yellowstone. I feel like it was just dumb luck in a couple of instances that he didn’t end up in my favorite non-fiction book, Death in Yellowstone. And if he was out there doing all that when he definitely knew better, it makes one wonder what all the other Fenn hunters, at least the ones who didn’t die in their own mishaps, were up to on other people’s property and on federal land and in the wonders of nature. The stuff we know about, the attempted kidnapping of Fenn’s granddaughter and the break-in on his property and the deaths, are bad enough, but how many fragile locations were trespassed on and how many historically important sites were dug up in the process of wild solves? I agree with US attorney Bob Muarray, who prosecuted another hunter who dug into a historic cemetery on Yellowstone property in search of the treasure (despite Fenn stating on more than one occasion that the treasure was NOT buried, which... to be fair, in the photos the finder eventually released, the treasure when he came upon it sure looked buried to me!), who said, "A national park is no place to stage an adult treasure hunt motivated by greed.”
![]() |
| Signage I saw during my 2014 trip to Yellowstone. |
I feel like there was something unfair in Fenn’s game, maybe something that he didn’t even realize would be unfair when he created it, but definitely something he played on later and chose not to ameliorate. The finder stated that he solved the hunt by engaging in close reading of the poem, specifically with authorial intent in mind, combined with scanning related first-person material for how it could speak to the poem. Essentially, he conducted a college-level critical analysis as he was taught in Freshman Comp at his highly-selective liberal arts college. But he seems to have been about the only hunter, at least profiled in Barbarisi’s book, with this type of analytical skillset. Many others exhibited demonstrable ignorance in the methods of critical analysis, particularly creating a reasonable thesis statement backed up with textual evidence and a clear chain of logic connecting the two. This is evidenced by the multiple hunters who took the phrase “House of Brown” as an attempt at toilet humor, or the hunter who decided that Fenn’s direct statement that the treasure was north of Santa Fe meant she should search south of Santa Fe because if you go north all the way around the planet then you end up south again. As I had to explain to MANY of my own Freshman Comp students over the years, just because you can think of a connection doesn’t make it evidence-based and logical! Looking through so many hunters’ theories and seeing how most of them were based on what were essentially delusions was a depressing look at the level of higher-order thinking in the wider community, not to mention the tendency to devoutly buy into highly illogical and objectively fantastical conspiracy theories.
![]() |
| Yellowstone's geyser basin, 2014. |
But what I feel like these hunters who lacked analytical skills and critical thinking brought to the hunt is a level of fandom that Barbarisi strongly hinted that Fenn was pretty into. The conventions held in his honor read as more like tent revivals, with more effort focused on Fenn’s cult of personality than on parsing the poem and debating its interpretations. A group of PhD students would NEVER! I wish there had been an academic conference held on the treasure, because those conference papers would have been ON POINT. This tendency towards cults of personality also reads to me as a symptom of a culturally illiterate society that lacks critical thinking skills.
@hersh3y The Forrest Fenn treasure ending is SUS! Jump down this conspiracy rabbit hole to connect the truth! #conspiracy #forrestfenn #thechase ♬ original sound - Hershey
I think that the finder’s ultimate refusal to offer the most rabid hunters full closure by revealing every detail of his solution and his complete methodology, up to the point of refusing for a long to time to even disclose the location of the treasure, is also evidence of these disparate views of the hunt taken by disparate segments of society. Like fans of a TV show that’s abruptly canceled, these rabid hunters seem furious that the hunt didn’t have a TV-friendly conclusion, and many have gone on to further their conspiracy theories and write their own fanfic that ranges from “the hunt was rigged” to “it’s still not solved here’s where it actually is.” Some of the comments on the finder's Medium article are so chilling! To be fair, it DOES feel crazy for someone to have expended all that effort and time and money--multiple hunters were bankrupted by their hunt!--and not only not find the treasure, but also not find out how close you were to the treasure and what you got right and where you went wrong. But nobody asked these people to become this obsessed, or promised them a fruitful resolution to their obsession. Nobody owed them anything.
![]() |
| Castle Geyser, 2014. |
The thing that disenchanted me the most about the concept of the modern-day treasure hunt is the description of taxes. So, you spend all that money and time finding a treasure, but it’s all gold nuggets and ancient relics and shit so you’ve got to sell it before you can actually have any spendable money from it in your hands, but in the meantime the government works their asses off to estimate all the taxes you owe for the treasure, with a value estimate that you may or may not actually achieve when you sell it, and then you have to pay those taxes, which might be $500,000, BEFORE you’ve actually got any actual treasure money in your hands?
No, thank you. As with most get rich quick schemes, this one is way too slow and I’m way too lazy to ever.
P.P.S. Want to follow along with my craft projects, books I'm reading, road trips to weird old cemeteries, looming mid-life crisis, and other various adventures on the daily? Find me on my Craft Knife Facebook page!
























.jpg)

.jpg)


.jpg)
.jpg)






